Petrifying Product Reviews

Based on 127 reviews
98%
(125)
2%
(2)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
My new favorite candle

I love this candle! It smells exactly like hot buttered popcorn.

The orange and vanilla combination is just right.not too citrus with a touch of woodsy and creamy vanilla, I could burn this one all day.

L
Stranger Things Bloodthirsty Bundle
Lex Tee
Stranger Things

I absolutely love the Stranger Things collection. The newest addition of the Hellfire Club did not disappoint! I love the candles with a sweetness to them. Scoops Ahoy has always been one of my favs and was so glad to see it back.

Haunted beach?

I can smell the apple taffy and salt water taffy and a hint of a Carmel glazed popcorn. Love the creativity and can't wait to see what they next concoction will be! Fast shipping and thoughtful packaging!

Not your basic candles!

Fantastic shop! I love the creativity and attention to detail. I love scented candles but bored of the big box store candles, so glad I found these!

L
They're Coming to Get You Barbara Candle
Lisa
Loch Ness

I love the scent. Every thing I have bought from SOF has been high quality. My husband enjoys the scents also. Packaging is fantastic.

S
Camp Crystal Lake Candle
Sarah Pierce
Camp Crystal Lake candle

I love the scent of this candle, very fresh and watery. I've always gotten excellent service from Smell of Fear, and the candles and wax melts are incredible!

M
Camp Crystal Lake Candle
Meg
Wonderful Service, Even Better Product

I love my candle and every candle I have ordered from The Smell of Fear. The service is second to none, and the quality of the candles is well worth the price. She could probably charge more for these and I would still pay... THAT's HOW GOOD THESE ARE. The smell is strong, but not overpowering and the packaging and marketing is perfect for a spooky chick like me. I love these and will order more soon.

M
We're Going to Get You Candle
Montse Guijarro
Ash Williams my beloved

This is the second Evil Dead themed candle that I've bought and I can't compare the two because they're both such unique takes on one of my favorite movies but I can say that this smells wonderful. The combination of old books with a woodsy scent was such a good decision, I'll definitely be rebuying this one if it gets released again.

M
Roll in Zee Hay
Montse Guijarro
One of my favorites

I've had this candle for a few years now, I bought it when it was listed on the The Smell of Fear etsy shop. I used to burn it regularly because it smelled so good but then I stopped for some time because I bought other candles, but I was burning it a few days ago while watching Young Frankenstein and wow, I had forgotten just how good of a scent it has. There's nothing overwhelming and all the different notes work so well together.

Such a good candle!

I’m the type of person that loves the smell of coffee so much that I sometimes make coffee just so that the smell can fill the entire house. I don’t have to do that now that I have this candle though, because it smells like the most delicious French Roast coffee. I absolutely love it

K
Insist on Your Cup of Stars Candle
Kyra Loch

Insist on Your Cup of Stars Candle

Amazing candle

This candle smells amazing and was packed in a really cute bag as well! The shipping was fast and I had no issues. I will definitely be ordering from here again!

M
We're Going to Get You Candle
Melissa W.
We're going to get you

It's great! The scent is spot on: old books and dark woods. I love the design of the label, too!

M
Cask of Amontillado Candle
Matt Strawbridge
Amontillado is the best!

This was the first candle I ever got with The Smell of Fear, waaaay back when the business was starting out. I’m so delighted that the business is thriving because the work out into these candles is amazing! Plus the careful shipping is very much appreciated. And Amontillado is STILL my favorite scent (tho several others come close). Highly recommended shop!!

K
I Move the Stars for No One Candle
K.H.
Yay! David Bowie!

This candle has a lovely spicy peach smell. It’s a little on the petite side, definitely packable, or good for a small nightstand—but don’t be surprised when you order the smaller size. The clever theming of these candles can’t be beat!

B
Squat Sinister Skulls
Bekka Bergamot
Incredible Scents

I love these squat skull candles! I have reused the skulls as vases and love that they come in so many fun colors and fantastic scents. I personally love foodie scents, so I love both the chocolate covered cherry scent and the red hot cinnamon scents. I am slowly collecting all of the colors and different scents. :)

B
Mary Shelley Candle
Bekka Bergamot
Beautiful & Great Smelling Candle

I absolutely love the artwork for this candle label and the scent smells divine!

S
Head to the Winchester Candle
Samantha
Head to the Winchester

Smells just like beer and pub snacks. Amazing!

K
Danse Macabre Candle
Katie Kaderbeck
Another hit!

This is truly a remarkable scent. The quality of candles from The Smell of Fear is second to none.

K
A Life in a Day Candle
Katie Kaderbeck
Excellence as usual

This is truly a remarkable scent. The quality of candles from The Smell of Fear is second to none.

K
I Move the Stars for No One Candle
Katie Kaderbeck
The Best Candles

This is truly a remarkable scent. The quality of candles from The Smell of Fear is second to none.

K
I Move the Stars for No One Candle
Kathleen Davies
"I've Brought You a Present!"

I purchased "I Move the Stars for No One" for my Labyrinth-loving daughter who lives on the other side of the country. She was thrilled with the packaging and absolutely blown away by the spicy, peachy scent. It made her feel like she was right there in Jareth's castle. The Smell of Fear does wonderful, whimsical scents that will place you in your favorite fantasy world.

V
Twist the Bones & Bend the Back Candle
Valerie Schmidt
My favorite candle!!

This candle scent is so unique and incredible. This is my all time favorite candle and will never be without it. Buy it, you will not be disappointed. Never smelled another candle even remotely close to this!

R
Jack's Lament Candle
Robin Beidelman
So dreamy

I absolutely love this scent, it is the perfect blend of sweet and spicy. I think I have actually already burned it, that's how much I liked it!