Spine-Tingling Subscription Box MONTHLY
Spine-Tingling Subscription Box MONTHLY
Spine-Tingling Subscription Box MONTHLY
Spine-Tingling Subscription Box MONTHLY
Spine-Tingling Subscription Box MONTHLY
Spine-Tingling Subscription Box MONTHLY
The Smell of Fear

Spine-Tingling Subscription Box MONTHLY

Regular price $24.99 $0.00 Unit price per
Shipping calculated at checkout.

Get bloodcurdling brand new releases before they hit the shop & sell out! Boxes will contain candles, a petrifying pack of wooden matches, and a terrifying treat or two. Always ships free within the US! You can choose from the following sizes:

  • Two (2)freaky full-sized (8oz or 8.5oz) in clear or colored glass with metal lid
  • Two (2) scary small (4oz) in amber glass with metal lid
  • or
  • Three (3) terrifyingly tiny (2oz) in silver tin - (third candle will match theme of the month)

*Glass Variant Size Pictured for Box Selection*

Product Overview

  • Orders placed on or after the 1st of the month will receive the following month's new releases. For example, an order placed on August 5th will receive September's releases. 
  • Boxes will ship by the first week of each new month.  
  • If more than 2 new releases in a month, sample sizes of additional releases will be included in the full-sized or small. 
  • Extras will be a range of items and can be anything from stickers, bookmarks, collaborations with other makers, etc.
  • Listed price is per month
  • Specialty glassware not available in subscription boxes but will sometimes be offered as occasional upgrade
  • Ships FREE within the United States. 
  • Subscriptions automatically renew. Cancel anytime.

Customer Reviews

Based on 6 reviews

The scents are amazing! Excellent products! I look forward to them every month!

Danielle Raiff

I love this subscription box in general, but especially May is for Monsters. I love dinosaurs, especially Jurassic Park. Not only did this month include a Jurassic Park themed candle, but I also loved the little dinosaur extras that Jillian included.

Stacey Hall

Love the variety of candle scents. Such unique scents as well! These burn exceptionally well and clean. The horror theme is spot on! You can’t find a more perfect horror candle!

Anielle Troyan
Love my sub box!

Great way to snag the new releases before they sell out! And the extras are always super sweet!

Angela Territo

I love the subscription box! I always get quality candles that are clearly made with love and care. Jillian is amazing with communication.

Customer Reviews
5.0 Based on 7 Reviews
Write a Review

Thank you for submitting a review!

Your input is very much appreciated. Share it with your friends so they can enjoy it too!

Filter Reviews:
Danielle R.
United States United States
Extra goodies

I love all the candles and the extra goodies in this subscription box! I'm so happy I signed up for this.

Stacey H.
United States United States

This was my first subscription box and I couldn’t have been more excited! I’m usually very picky with candles, however I have loved all your candles! I think I’m up to 6 now, lol! They burn clean, scents are exquisite, and the horror theme is spot on. Best horror themed candles ever!!

Anielle T.
United States United States
Best candles EVER

Absolutely amazing! All of the scents are scrumptious and unique and the labels are truly gorgeous. The candles have very impressive scent throw, lit or unlit. Jillian pays so much attention to every single detail and that’s why I’ll never buy candles anywhere else!!

A The Smell of Fear  Customer
Liz W.
United States United States
The monster was the best friend I ever had

Freakishly Fantastic!! New candle day is my favorite day! I love knowing I am getting my hands on limited edition scents and I don't have to scramble to order. Smell of Fear makes it so easy and convenient. I have yet to be disappointed by a scent! They stave off the existential dread and ennui and seemingly impending apocalypse! At least for the month...please...keep them coming??!! :)

Gailyn N.
United States United States
Just Do It

I've been using aromatherapy as a way to stay sane during this pandemic. Needless to say, I've gone through a lot of candles and wax melts. Since I found this company last Spring, it's been my go-to shop. The quality is high, the scent variety is unreal, and the added fun of a horror theme sparks a ton of joy in my spooky heart. If you use candles regularly, or just want to treat yourself to something fun, I highly recommend getting the subscription box.